The Pirate King's Private Stock

It goes without saying that Pirates and Rum go together like tall ships and open water, but with so many Rum choices on the market today it can be tough to choose one that meets your expectations.

As a service to the Pirate community, I have spent years researching this topic and compiled the list below to help you better navigate to the choice that suits you best.  If you know of a Rum I have missed, EMAIL ME and let me know!

 

Click on the name of a rum below to read it's review

 

Rating

Name of Rum

Rum Type

Three Stars
3 Stars

10 Cane

White

Three Stars
3.5 Stars

267 Rum Infusions Mango

Infused
(Mango)

pending

267 Rum Infusions Wild Berry

Infused
(Berry)

One Star
1 Star

Admiral Nelson Dark Premium Rum

Dark

Three Stars
3.5 Stars

Angostura 1824

Dark

Four and a half stars
4.5 Stars!

Angostura 1919

Dark

Three Stars
3 Stars

Appleton Estate Extra

Dark

pending

Appleton Estate Reserve

 

pending

Appleton Estate VX Rum

 

pending

Appleton Extra

 

pending

Appleton V/X

 

pending

Araku Coffee Liquer

Infused
(Coffee)

pending

Bacardi 1873

 

pending

Bacardi Coco Coconut Rum

Infused
(Coconut)

Two and a half stars
2.5 Stars!

Bacardi Gold

Gold

pending

Bacardi Island Breeze Lime

Infused
(Lime)

Two stars
2 Stars!

Bacardi Island Breeze Wild Berry

Infused
(Berry)

pending

Bacardi Limon Citrus Rum

Infused
(Lemon/Lime)

pending

Bacardi O Orange Rum

Infused
(Orange)

Two and a half stars
2 Stars!

Bacardi Razz Raspberry Rum

Infused
(Raspberry)

pending

Bacardi Ron Solera

 

Two stars
2 Stars!

Bacardi Select

Dark

pending

Bacardi Vanila Vanilla Rum

Infused
(Vanilla)

pending

Barbarossa Coconut Rum

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Barbarossa Original Spiced Rum

 

pending

Barrique Aged Origine Rum

 

pending

Barrows' Hors D'Age Cigar Blended Rum

 

pending

Beachcomber Coconut

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Beachcomber Rum Crème

Cream

pending

Belize Travelers One Barrel

 

pending

Blackbeard's Reserve

 

pending

Brinley Gold Coconut Rum

Infused
(Coconut )

pending

Brinley Gold Coffee Rum

Infused
(Coffee)

pending

Brinley Gold Lime Rum

Infused
(Lime )

pending

Brinley Gold Mango Rum

Infused
(Mango )

pending

Brinley Gold Vanilla Rum

Infused
(Vanilla)

pending

British Navy Pussers Rum

 

Three Stars
3.5 Stars

Brugal Añejo

Gold

pending

Cacique Rum

 

pending

Captain Morgan Parrot Bay Coconut

Infused

pending

Captain Morgan Parrot Bay Passion Fruit

Infused

pending

Captain Morgan Parrot Bay Pineapple

Infused

Three Stars
3 Stars

Captain Morgan Spiced Rum

Spiced

Four Stars 4 Stars

Captain Morgan's Private Stock

Spiced

Three Stars
3 Stars

Captain Morgan's Tattoo Rum

Spiced

pending

Carlisle Reef 5 year

 

pending

Cartavio 12 Year

 

pending

Castillo Spiced Rum

Spiced

pending

Clement Liqueur Creole Shrubb

 

pending

Clement Premiere Canne Premium Light Rum

 

pending

Clement Rhum VSOP

 

Four Stars 4 Stars

Cockspur 12 year

Dark

pending

Cockspur 5 Star

 

pending

Cockspur Fine Rum

 

pending

Conch Republic Dark Rum

Dark

pending

Coronation Khukri XXX

 

pending

Coruba Jamaican Rum

 

pending

Coyopa Rum

 

pending

Crisma Rum Cream Liqueur

Cream

Two and a half stars
2.5 Stars!

Cruzan Banana

Infused
(Banana)

pending

Cruzan Black Diamond

 

pending

Cruzan Black Strap

 

pending

Cruzan Black Strap Rum

 

pending

Cruzan Citrus

Infused
(Citrus)

pending

Cruzan Coconut

Infused
(Coconut)

Three Stars
3 Stars

Cruzan Estate Dark

Gold

pending

Cruzan Estate Diamond Rum

 

pending

Cruzan Single Barrel

 

pending

Cruzan Single Barrel Rum

 

pending

Diplomatico

 

pending

Dogfish Head Brown Honey

 

Three Stars
3.5 Stars

Don Q Grand Añejo Conmemorativo

Dark

pending

Don Q Crystal

 

pending

Don Q Limon

 

Four Stars 4 Stars

Doorley's XO

Dark

Four Stars 4 Stars

Dulseda

Cream

pending

El Dorado 25 Year

 

pending

El Dorado Special Reserve 12 year

 

pending

English Harbor

 

Half a Star 0.5 Stars

Fire in de Hole Erotic Rum

 

pending

Flor de Caña 12 Year Centenario

 

Four Stars
4 Stars

Flor de Cana Gold (4 year)

Gold

pending

Flor de Cana Grand Reserve (7 year)

 

pending

Flor De Cana Limon

Infused
(Lemon/Lime)

pending

Foursquare

 

Four Stars
4 Stars

Gosling's Black Seal

Dark

Five Stars
5 Stars

Gosling's Family Reserve

Dark

pending

Goslings Gold

 

pending

Hang Loose Vanilla Rum

Infused
(Vanilla)

pending

Happy Rum

 

pending

Havana Club 15

 

Four and a half Stars
4.5 Stars

Havana Club Anejo Blanco

White

pending

Heaven Hill Rum

 

pending

Jack Tar Superior

 

pending

Khukri

 

Two and a half Stars
2.5 Stars

Malibu Passion Fruit Rum

Infused

pending

Malibu Pineapple

Infused
(Pineapple)

pending

Marti Coconut

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Maui Dark

Dark

pending

Monte Cristo 12 Year Aged Rum

 

pending

Mount Gay Eclipse

 

pending

Mount Gay Mango

Infused
(Mango)

pending

Mount Gay Special Reserve Light Rum

 

pending

Mount Gay Sugar Cane Rum

 

pending

Mount Gay Vanilla

Infused
(Vanilla)

Four Stars
4 Stars

Mount Gay XO

Dark

pending

Myers Dark Rum

Dark

pending

Myers's Legend

 

pending

Myers's Original Dark

Dark

pending

Nassau Royale Liqueur

 

pending

New Orleans Amber

 

pending

New Orleans Crystal

 

pending

Old Mill Gold Rum

 

pending

Old Monk 7 year Blended

 

pending

Old Monk XXX

 

pending

Ole Nassau

 

pending

Pirate's Choice Molasses Reef

 

One Star
1 Star

Pitú Cachaça

White
(Cane)

pending

Plantation Grand Reserve Barbados Rum

 

pending

Plantation Rum - Barbados

 

pending

Plantation Rum - Jamaica

 

pending

Plantation Rum - Trinidad

 

pending

Pirate Cranberry Rum

 

pending

Pusser's Battle of Trafalgar Commemorative

 

pending

Pusser's Blue Label

 

pending

Pyrat Blanco

 

pending

Pyrat Cask 1623

 

pending

Pyrat Cask 23

 

pending

Pyrat XO

 

Four and a half Stars
4.5 Stars

Pyrat XO Reserve

Dark

pending

Redrum

 

pending

Redrum Voodoo Spiced Rum

Spiced

pending

Rhum Barbancourt 15 year

 

pending

Rhum Barbancourt 8 year

 

pending

Rhum J.M. 10 year

 

pending

Rhum J.M. Exceptional VSOP

 

pending

Rhum J.M. Gold

 

pending

Rhum J.M. Les Heritiers Crassous de Medeuil

 

pending

Rogue Spirits Dark

Dark

pending

Ron Abuelo Anejo

 

pending

Ron Anejo Anniversario Pampero

 

pending

Ron Barcelo Dorado

 

pending

Ron Barcelo Gran Anejo

 

pending

Ron Barcelo Imperial

 

pending

Ron Botran Anejo

 

pending

Ron Botran Etiqueta Blanca

 

pending

Ron Centenario Anejo Especial

 

pending

Ron Cortez White

 

pending

Ron deBarrilito Three Star

 

pending

Ron Del Barralito

 

Four Stars
4 Stars

Ron Matusalem Gran Reserva

Dark

pending

Ron Matusalem Platino

 

pending

Ron Matusalem Rum Gran Reserva 15 year

 

pending

Ron Medellin Rum

 

pending

Ron Pampero Anniversario

 

pending

Ron Vicaro Coconut

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Ron Vicaro Pineapple

Infused
(Pineapple)

pending

Ron Zacapa Centenario 15yr

 

pending

Ron Zacapa Centenario 23 yr

 

pending

Rum Jumbie Liqueur

 

pending

Sailor Jerry Spiced Navy Rum

 

pending

Sailors Cherry

Infused
(Cherry)

pending

Sailors Coconut

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Sailors Silver

 

pending

Sailors Spiced

Spiced

pending

Saint James Hors D'Age

 

pending

Santa Teresa 1796

 

pending

Santa Teresa Superior Silver

Silver

pending

Santa Theresa 1796

 

pending

Santero Ron 21 Años

 

pending

Screech from Newfoundland

 

pending

Sea Wynde

 

pending

Sea Wynde Pot Still Rum

 

pending

St. James Extra Old

 

Three Stars
3 Stars

Starr African Rum

White

Two and a half Stars
2.5 Stars

Three Palms Spiced Rum

Spiced

pending

Tommy Bahama Golden Sun Rum

 

pending

Tortuga 140 proof

 

pending

Tortuga Spiced Rum

 

pending

Trader Vic's Authentic Spiced Rum

Spiced

pending

Trader Vic's Coconut Rum

Infused
(Coconut)

pending

Trader Vic's Pineapple Rum

Infused
(Pineapple)

Five Stars! 5 Stars!

Treaty Oak Rum

White
(Silver)

pending

Tropic Isle Palms

 

pending

Tropical Isle Palms Banana Rum

Infused
(Banana)

pending

Tropical Isle Palms Mango Rum

Infused
(Mango)

pending

Vizcaya VXOP

 

pending

Westerhall Estate Rum

 

pending

Zaya Gran Reserva

 

Click on the Piece of Eight to return to the Main Page